Hot composting (the Berkeley method): can you really make compost in 18 days?

Print

Compost in 18 days, when it usually takes four to nine months in a bin: the promise of the “Berkeley method” is hard to resist. It's widely shared on gardening and permaculture blogs, often presented as a miracle recipe.

It really does work, as long as you follow some fairly demanding rules. Here's what hot composting involves, how to do it, what it actually delivers, and why it isn't right for every garden.

“Cold” compost and “hot” compost

In most gardens, compost is made “cold”: you add scraps day by day, and decomposition moves along slowly. Home composting usually happens without any noticeable rise in temperature. There's nothing wrong with that: the compost still forms, just more slowly.

Hot composting, on the other hand, aims to trigger and sustain the hot phase of composting, which we describe in our guide How is compost made? Above about 104 °F (40 °C), heat-loving microorganisms take over. From 131 °F (55 °C), many germs that cause disease in people or plants are destroyed. But above about 149 °F (65 °C), the heat also kills beneficial microorganisms, and decomposition slows down. The whole art of hot composting is staying within this range.

What it takes to succeed

The Berkeley method relies on four conditions.

Enough volume, built all at once

The pile should measure at least 3.3 ft by 3.3 ft (1 m by 1 m) at the base and about 4.9 ft (1.5 m) high. Any smaller and it loses too much heat. Above all, it's built all at once: nothing gets added afterward. So you need to gather all your materials ahead of time.

A well-balanced mix

The method aims for a carbon-to-nitrogen ratio of 25–30 to 1, by weight. In practice, that works out to roughly one part green materials (grass clippings, peels, manure) to two parts brown materials (leaves, straw, wood chips). We explain these concepts in our guide Green and brown materials.

Chopped-up materials

Branches and woody materials need to be shredded. That said, there's no need to reduce everything to crumbs: roughly cut pieces will do.

The right moisture level

Each layer gets watered as you build the pile. A good rule of thumb: a handful squeezed in a gloved hand should release only about one drop.

Some gardeners place a “starter” in the heart of the pile: a few plants such as stinging nettle or comfrey, a little manure, or a shovelful of old compost. As we'll see in our guide Compost activators, this boost is optional.

The turning schedule

Here's the typical schedule:

1. Day 1: build the pile in alternating layers, watering each one.
2. Days 2 to 4: let it rest. The pile heats up.
3. Day 5: first turn. Material from the outside goes to the center, and vice versa.
4. Days 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, and 17: turn the pile every other day, checking the temperature.
5. Day 18: the pile has cooled down; it's dark and crumbly.

The heat usually peaks between day 6 and day 8. Turning a 35-cubic-foot (1 m³) pile with a fork, seven times in two weeks, is real physical work. The easiest approach is to have two spots side by side, for example two bays of a wooden composting system such as the Compostys wooden composter, and move the pile from one to the other.

Did you know?

After 18 days, most of the work is done, but all compost then goes through a cooling and curing phase that lasts several months. Before using it for starting seeds, check its maturity with the cress test.

Measuring the temperature

The ideal tool is a compost thermometer with a long probe that reaches the heart of the pile. The target is 131–149 °F (55–65 °C). For comparison, a well-managed pile can reach 129–160 °F (54–71 °C).

Without a thermometer, your hand gives you a first clue: if the inside of the pile feels uncomfortably hot to the touch, it has probably reached temperature. A few signs to watch for:

• The pile stays lukewarm: it's probably short on nitrogen, water, or volume. Turn it and add green materials.
• The pile gets too hot, smells strong, and sinks quickly: too much nitrogen. Add a little sawdust or wood chips when you turn it.
• A white, felt-like layer appears: this is a sign the temperature is too high; it goes away as the pile cools.
• The pile no longer heats up after turning: it has reached a stable state.

The big advantage: getting rid of seeds

Hot composting has one major benefit: the heat destroys a good share of weed seeds and germs. A well-built pile reaches about 129 °F (54 °C) within a week, which is enough to kill many seeds. The toughest ones, however, need 30 days at 145 °F (63 °C) or more.

Let's be honest: even when it's well managed, 18-day hot composting offers no absolute guarantee. The edges of the pile stay cooler, which is why thorough turning matters. To be on the safe side, we still recommend leaving out weeds that have gone to seed and diseased plants, as we explain in our guide on debatable waste.

Limitations and realistic expectations for a home garden

The Berkeley method is fascinating, but it isn't for everyone:

• You need a lot of material at once: 35 cubic feet (1 m³) is far more than a kitchen produces in several months. It works best in fall or spring, when your yard provides plenty of grass clippings, leaves, and prunings.
• It takes time and energy: a complete turn every two days.
• It uses water, especially in summer.
• It doesn't replace your everyday composter, where you add your food scraps as you go.

For most families, “cold” compost, mixed regularly with an aerator such as the Brass'Compost, remains the simplest solution. Hot composting can be a useful addition, once or twice a year, to process a large volume of yard waste.

Key takeaways

Berkeley method: at least 35 cubic feet (1 m³) built all at once, one part green to two parts brown, the moisture of a wrung-out sponge, and a turn every two days starting on day 5. The compost you get on day 18 still needs to cure before you use it for starting seeds.

What about compost tumblers?

The compost tumbler is sometimes promoted as an easy way to hot compost. It can indeed heat up, especially in summer, if you fill it all at once. But in cold weather it struggles to get hot, and what comes out is still fresh compost that needs to cure for several more months. We cover its real strengths, and how long to expect it to take, in our guide Compost tumbler.

In summary

Hot composting with the Berkeley method produces well-decomposed material in 18 days, as long as you gather at least 35 cubic feet (1 m³) of waste at once, pay close attention to the mix and moisture, and turn the pile every other day while monitoring the temperature. It destroys a good share of weed seeds, with no absolute guarantee, and the finished product benefits from further curing before you use it for starting seeds. It's a worthwhile technique for processing a large volume of yard waste, but for most households, well-maintained “cold” compost remains the simplest solution.

Related products

Preorder

245L Maze Rotating Composter with Dual Chambers

Effortless outdoor composting

$231.67 €207.50

Best Seller

Bokashi Composter Confort

3.7-gallon (14-liter) capacity, sold individually or as a set of 2

$45.59 €40.83

Best Seller

Bokashi EM compost activator | 1 kg bag

Sold individually or in sets of 2 or 3 bags

$8.02 €7.18

Brass'Compost easy compost aerator

Make breaking down organic waste easier and faster

$35.26 €31.58

Other topics in the guide

Vermicomposting30 fact sheets →Bokashi24 fact sheets →EM microorganisms26 fact sheets →