Worm composter or traditional compost bin: which is right for your food scraps?

Cutting down on food scraps is a great idea, but it quickly runs into a very practical first question: which system should you choose? Whether you go with a backyard compost bin or a worm composter, both methods recycle organic matter, but they don't work the same way and don't suit the same situations. Here's what you need to know to make the right choice for your home, your waste, and your goals.

Two methods, one goal

Traditional composting means piling up organic waste outdoors (in a plastic or wooden bin, or in a pile) and letting the microorganisms, insects, and fungi in the soil gradually break it down over several months. It's known as a “hot” process: the fermentation of large volumes of material gives off heat, which speeds up decomposition but requires space and time.

Vermicomposting, on the other hand, relies on composting worms (Eisenia) to digest the waste directly. The process is “cold,” with no rise in temperature, which makes it suitable for indoor use — we explain this principle in detail in our guide What is a worm composter?

The factors that make the difference

Available space

This is often the deciding factor. A backyard compost bin needs a dedicated, sheltered outdoor spot in contact with the soil. A worm composter, by contrast, fits neatly into a kitchen, pantry, basement, garage, or even onto a balcony: its compact, odor-free design makes it the only realistic option for anyone who lives in an apartment or doesn't have a yard.

Speed of breakdown

Backyard composting is a slow process: allow several months, sometimes more than a year, before you have finished compost. Vermicomposting is considerably faster, since composting worms digest a large share of their body weight in waste every day. The first vermicompost harvests usually come after three to six months — the time it takes for the worms to colonize all the trays. Once your worm bin is up to cruising speed, harvesting becomes much more regular: you can then expect to harvest one tray roughly once a month.

What it can take

Backyard compost is the most generous in terms of volume: it takes grass clippings, shredded branches, and large quantities of fallen leaves — materials that worms digest poorly or not at all. A worm composter, on the other hand, excels with small, regular amounts of food scraps (peels, coffee grounds, filters, eggshells), with a few restrictions that we cover in our guide What do earthworms eat?

Day-to-day upkeep

Backyard compost needs to be turned regularly to stay well aerated, but keeping an eye on it is fairly undemanding once the pile is established. A worm composter needs more frequent but lighter attention: small, regular feedings, a quick moisture check, and that's all there is to it.

Key takeaways

Backyard compost processes large volumes slowly; a worm composter processes small volumes quickly, without needing even a square yard (1 m²) of ground.

What you get

Backyard compost produces an organic soil amendment that needs to be spread in fairly large quantities. Vermicomposting produces two fertilizers in one: vermicompost, which is highly concentrated, and worm tea (or leachate), a liquid fertilizer you can use right away, diluted, on your plants. Both are especially rich in microorganisms that benefit the soil, and vermicompost has about 10 times the fertilizing power of regular compost: a few handfuls do the job where you would need wheelbarrows full of backyard compost.

Why more and more households are turning to vermicomposting

For an urban household with no yard or only limited outdoor space, a worm composter is often the only way to stop throwing food scraps in the trash can. It doesn't smell when it's well balanced, it's easy to tuck away, and it gives you a usable result in just a few months. It's also a wonderful family project: watching the worms, following how they breed, and harvesting the fruits of their labor is as educational as it is eco-friendly, especially with kids.

Backyard composting is of course still well worth it for anyone with outdoor space who produces large volumes of yard waste (grass clippings, prunings, leaves) in addition to food scraps — and the two methods are far from incompatible: many households with a yard choose to combine an outdoor compost pile for yard waste with a worm composter for the kitchen, which is more convenient day to day.

Key takeaways

Choosing between vermicomposting and traditional composting isn't just a question of efficiency: above all, it's about matching the method to your lifestyle.

How to get started

If vermicomposting fits your situation, head over to our guide How to start your worm composter for all the practical details. There you'll also find our range of worm composters, both stacking-tray and continuous-flow models, suited to every setup, from a studio apartment to a house with a yard.

Related products

New Arrival

City Worms Worm Composter | 2 trays

2 or 3 trays, 2.9 gallons (11 liters) usable per tray

$65.44 €58.25

WORMcube Worm Composter | 2 trays

2 or 3 trays, 3.3 gallons (12.5 liters) usable per tray

$73.95 €65.83

Compostys wooden composter | 305 liters

PEFC-certified spruce wood

$130.12 €115.83

Urbalive Worm Composter | 2 trays

2 or 3 trays with wooden legs, 3.7 gallons (14 liters) usable per tray

$139.49 €124.17